The '29 Stutz used a center crossmember that was little more than a sophisticated K-member (For a look at a classic K-member, dig up a picture of the 1932 Ford Frame), that was more like a conventional C-channel crossmember with two parts, riveted back to back (or "web" to "web") with the 4 legs angling out from each other more like a "bow tie" than a really functioning X-member, which would have it's center "spine" (if you will) positioned longitudinally down the center of the frame, as with the Cord L-29 and all subsequent chassis using an X-crossmember.  As done by Stutz, it probably did have some torsional resistance, but not nearly as stiff as the L-29--which car did set the pattern for this sort of chassis design for the next 25-30 years.
 
Here's a pic of one:  http://forums.aaca.org/uploads/monthly_11_2014/post-68778-143142820182.jpg
 
Art Anderson
Hi James, I would also post this question in the general discussion forum. There is a forum member with the ID of Xframe whose hobby is the research of same. 
I am not sure he frequents the ACD forums. 
The '29 Stutz used a center crossmember that was little more than a sophisticated K-member   As done by Stutz, it probably did have some torsional resistance, but not nearly as stiff as the L-29--which car did set the pattern for this sort of chassis design for the next 25-30 years.
 
Here's a pic of one:  http://forums.aaca.org/uploads/monthly_11_2014/post-68778-143142820182.jpg
 
Art Anderson
 
Art... It has been a while since my last visit and did not see your reply until now, sorry.
 
Is there some sort of standard or formula required to be considered a true X such as leg degree of angle or length for it to be effective?
 
The photo you posted showing a Stutz is the same design that Packard used on their 1932 Standard 8 chassis seen in their sales brochure described as a X (attached).
 
I have since found out that the Cord L-29 X was not the first production car to use the same design.  The 1924-1927 Delage GL also had the same outreaching X design used for torque according to Autocar articles.  That X was designed by the same person who designed the Hotchkiss model AK chassis -Maurice Sainturant. (attached - seen in front at the Paris show).
 
Eric
Anyone else wants to chime in, please do.  This may not be an easy question to answer and the more heads the better.
To join in the conversation, you must be a club member.
You’re welcome to read and like every post. Members can reply and start topics of their own.
