
Cool photo Dave.  Murphy Convertible Sedan.  That body was built in the most quantity,  something like 45.
So what were the logistics?  Chassis constructed in Indiana, shipped to Murphy in Pasadena, completed car shipped back to Indiana and then someone went for a joyride to Chicago?

Barney EatonSep 19, 2024
 
It was at the ACD show two weeks ago. Correct on the owner info. A long time car collecting family has owned it for about 60 years. Body was a modern design done by one of the original designers of Duesenberg bodies. Sort of a 60's interpretation of a dream car. It's well done and performs great. 
 
 
 

Strother MacMinn drawing from one of Eberts books I believe.
 

Just wondering if it ever left the building.    I grew up in Frankfort Ind and the Goodwin funeral home has always has a small collection of cars. 
The original plan was just cars from Indiana and that is still probably true to the collection except for the Tucker.    Bill Miller is Bill Goodwins son in law
and Mr. Miller runs the place now and is a car guy.     Frankfort was also the location for a wood body manufacturer from 1937 until 1950 when "woodys" 
went away.    Mr. Miller purchased a 49-50 Plymouth woody a few years back that was made in Frankfort by US Body & Forging....however the locals
never knew that name......the plant name was USHCO. 

Steve,  they did ok.   The rear fenders and the rear portion of the roof don't quite work.   Sometimes drawings do not translate either as they are always elongated for effect.

edinmassSep 19, 2024 
It was at the ACD show two weeks ago. Correct on the owner info. A long time car collecting family has owned it for about 60 years. Body was a modern design done by one of the original designers of Duesenberg bodies. Sort of a 60's interpretation of a dream car. It's well done and performs great. 
 
 
 
In addition to the ACD event, it was shown at the Greenbrier in the last couple of years and there are photos of it at the event.   
 
alsancleSep 19, 2024Steve,  they did ok.   The rear fenders and the rear portion of the roof don't quite work.   Sometimes drawings do not translate either as they are always elongated for effect.
A.J.:
I suspect MacMinn created design for the 142.5" wb chassis. Roe notes it's the longer 153.5 wb.  Convertible Victorias are a touchy design in terms of the relationship among the various proportional elements.  Even at 145" wb the design can begin to lose the integration that is key to making the design 'work'.  It is toward the rear this one begins to lose that; the top shape and windows are off badly as well.   I suspect they failed to do a full-sized body draft of MacMinn's original design profile as a simple line drawing which was standard practice for coachbuilders.   It would have prevented most of the issues that makes this effort less than satisfactory.  The rear fenders 'shading' the upper portion of the tire is just wrong, note how MacMinn centers those in the rear wheelhouse.  The front has nearly the same problem.   On a grade scale, I'd give it a C-.
Steve  

 
Turning a drawing into an actual car is a major undertaking. Often times what is drawen is almost impossible to build in real life. I have the origional V-16 Cadillac roadster rendering done in 1929 for the 1930 model year cars......it's very close but not identicle to what was built..........which is an exception to the rule.
58L-Y8Sep 19, 2024
This J chassis has had this body on it for a larger portion of its life than any previous bodies on the chassis, which is kind of crazy when you think of it.
 
Since the topic of new coachwork has come up, at the 2025 Ameila Island show they are having a class featuring Fran Roxas and the new coachwork cars that he made. Some of the cars he built were copies of existing coachwork, and from what I understand the new coachwork bodies were built to better tolerances and gaps and they were square compared to the originals. There were 2 V16 Cadillac's that were catalog cars and never commissioned in period that he built off old prints that Strother MacMinn assisted on to make the bodies.  The interesting thing about new coachwork cars is that Pebble used to occasionally have a class for new coachwork cars back in the day, so they were socially accepted at one time. The bodies he made had a tag on the firewall that said coachwork by roxas, so he was never trying to conceal what they were.
edinmassSep 20, 2024 
Turning a drawing into an actual car is a major undertaking. Often times what is drawn is almost impossible to build in real life. 
Indeed, it is.  But, at the time this Duesenberg J received this body based on Strother MacMinn's original drawing, MacMinn was still with us (until 1998) and should have been intimately involved with the body drafts, ensuring the results were true to his original vision. 
 
If someone has a profile photograph of the car as it is presently, please share it with us.   How badly it's off the mark will become obvious.

It looks like it got the 17 inch drop centers at some point.
 

I've always said there's no Duesenberg I wouldn't happily take into my garage.
 
That statement is no longer valid. 
Matt HarwoodSep 20, 2024I've always said there's no Duesenberg I wouldn't happily take into my garage.
 
That statement is no longer valid. 
I assume that you have never seen the Father Divine throne car in person? I just can imagine the reverend walking into Bohman & Schwartz and saying "design me a Duesenberg that looks like a bus and can fit all of my Angels"
Regarding the rear renders and front fenders, as A.J. mentioned, they don't match. The rear fenders are kind of skirted, while the front fenders are fully open. I think the only way in which that could work is to put full skirts on the back. Of course, the white sidewall tires do it no justice. Car could use some current upgrades.
What counts most, I think , is that the hood hinge ( I presume) line, as well as the top of the door line , both fall to the A pillar, the car has a kind of a nick at that point, where it shouldn't be, that destroys in my opinion ,besides what's alreday mentioned . Johan
To join in the conversation, you must be a club member.
You’re welcome to read and like every post. Members can reply and start topics of their own.









