I figured out the problem. The new T.O. bearing is slightly different from the original factory bearing. The C1288 sleeve was manufactured with a wide flange onto which the bearing is supposed to come in full contact. (In other words, fully pressed into place.) If the modern bearing is fully pressed onto this flange, the non-rotating part of the bearing will come in contact with the flange, causing it to be frozen in place and not rotate as designed. Curt recommended putting a shim onto the sleeve first, which is the easiest method. My solution was to machine-off about a 16th of an inch around the perimeter of the flange. Both methods will work.